Don’t Cry For Me Argentina – Roast Beef Sandwiches

A roast beef sandwich with three kinds of onions.

As roast beef sandwiches go, this one is a doozy. But it’s not for the feint of heart. It’s a very chefy recipe and requiring multiple components, but this Don’t Cry For Me Argentina Roast Beef Sandwich is the best you’ll have.

Hello.  I’m Lisa… and I’m a cookbook hoarder.  Sometimes my obsession with cookbooks feels like I should be going to weekly hoarders anonymous meetings while simultaneously divesting my collection to those less fortunate than myself…. say, those with only 2 or 3 cookbooks.

Mine take up, not one, not two but three entire shelving units in my house.  So you might ask what would draw me to yet another cookbook.  

It was the titleA SUPER UPSETTING COOKBOOK ABOUT SANDWICHES,  by Tyler Kord, Chef No. 7 Sub.  And there was one sandwich in particular that caught my eye…  “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina Roast Beef Sandwiches —Makes 4 large sandwiches that will make you forget about the 2014 World Cup.”

Newsletter Signup
Join our community of food lovers!

Get my latest recipes, helpful kitchen tips and more good things each week in your inbox.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

I’ll admit, I spent an entire indulgent weekend floating around the pool, sipping adult beverages and devouring this book — and in my humble view, it’s a better read than an actual cookbook.  At least for a home-cook like me and probably you.  But maybe that’s the point.  To whet your appetite with quality food porn and charm the pants off you with his snarky,  stream-of-consciousness writing style.  This book reads like a compilation of blog posts and Tyler gripes, rants and generally kvetches his way through the cost of quality ingredients, the treatment of the animals  that so often are the source of those ingredients and the ultimate defense of a $9 sandwich.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Pithy and entertaining with sandwich names, descriptions and photography that will rev up your appetite, like:


Roast Beef – Fried Clams – Tomato Muchim – Grape Jelly Mayo


General Ignacio’s Chicken – Roquefort – Pickled Red Onions – Cilantro

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest


 General Ruffner’s Soft-Boiled Fried Egg – Cucumber Muchim – Blue Cheese.


Roasted Chicken – Fried Eggplant – Fresh Mozzarella – Arugula – Special Sauce

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

It is only when you resolve to make one of the sandwiches that you’ll begin cussing like drunken sailor.  Because these recipes — like all chef-y dishes — are made up of multiple components, each requiring their own subset of ingredients and instructions.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Let’s use the Don’t Cry For Me Argentina sandwich as an example.  Upon first glance it looks like a pretty straight forward recipe — only 7 “Ingredients”.  

Until you start breaking down those ingredients —

  • 2 pounds Roast Beef (recipe on page 13)
  • 1 cup Roasted Onions (recipe on page 172)
  • 1/2 cup Smoked French Dressing (recipe on page 162)
  • 1 cup Pickled Red Onions, (recipe on page 173)
  • 1/4 cup Fried Shallots, (recipe on page 175)
Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Literally the only 2 ingredients that didn’t have a corresponding recipe attached were the sub rolls and the scallions.  But I’m a food blogger, so I pressed on — pissed but undaunted.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

I figured I’d start with the roast beef.  It had a special wet rub that needed to rest on the roast overnight, so I began the assembly.  

I got out a bowl to assemble the rub and low-and-behold the 4th “ingredient” listed was Fried Shallots (recipe on page 175)

 I hadn’t even begun — and he was sending me off on another recipe.  Godammit!

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Then came the Smoked French Dressing.  Um, the recipe LITERALLY calls for setting up your grill or smoker and SMOKING 1/2 cup of ketchup for this sauce.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Here’s an excerpt from Tyler’s instructions:

“So you’re going to smoke ketchup now.  It will not get you high, but it will make everything you put it on taste like a really awesome hot dog…. you could put a lit charcoal briquette on a baking sheet, put a small pile of wood chips on top of it, put a dish of ketchup a few inches away from it, and cover the whole thing with a box, using a stick that’s taller than the box to hold it up at one end like you are trying to catch a cartoon rabbit.  Do a Google Images search for “cartoon rabbit trap” and you will see a few examples.”

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

Tyler goes on for several paragraphs about the flavor benefits of actually smoking the ketchup , before grudgingly admitting that you could be a wuss (my words, not his) and use liquid smoke instead.  Wuss reporting for duty!

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

I also confess that I didn’t make his pickled onions — because I still had a boatload leftover from that last sub sandwich I made.  I considered that a brief reprieve.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

I have to give the devil his due, though.  That roast beef was PERFECT.  Slow roasted at an uber-low temperature for 2 hours.  Resting for half an hour, then chilled to make it easier to slice.  It was tender and juicy with a smoky sweet, tongue tingly finish from the Ancho Chile.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

The sandwich itself was a two-handed, hunched over your plate affair.  

Scott and my friend, Nola were my guinea pigs and we scarfed down these roast beef sandwiches with equal parts unbridled gustatory exuberance and 20/20 hindsighted belly-busting regret.  

Was it great?  You bet.  Would I make it again?  Hell, no.  Instead, I’m scheduling stops at all three No. 7 Sub on my next trip to Manhattan!

Click here to get your own copy of A SUPER UPSETTING COOKBOOK ABOUT SANDWICHES.

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest

“I received this book from Blogging for Books for this review.”  This post contains affiliate links.  If you purchase the cookbook, I’ll get a small commission which doesn’t impact the price of the book for you.   I will use my commission to buy a sandwich at No. 7 Sub.

More amazing sandwich recipes:

Tried this recipe? Leave a rating and review.

Your comments and shares are invaluable to me and the thousands of readers who use this site daily. If you've made the recipe, leave a star rating and review. We want to hear how you liked it.

We'd love it if you shared the recipe with your friends on social media!

Don't Cry For Me Argentina - Roast Beef Sandwiches | Garlic & Zest
Print Pin
5 from 2 votes

Don’t Cry For Me Argentina Roast Beef Sandwiches

An over-the-top sandwich from Tyler Kord’s A Super Upsetting Book About Sandwiches
Author: Lisa Lotts
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Keyword roast beef, sandwich
Prep Time 1 hour
Cook Time 2 hours
Total Time 4 hours 25 minutes
Servings 8


For the Roast Beef

  • 1 2-3 pound Beef Eye of Round Roast
  • Kosher Salt
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 2 tablespoons shallots ifried, nstructions given
  • 2 tablespoons Ancho Chile Powder
  • 2 tablespoons molasses or kecap manis — I used molasses
  • pinch of salt
  • 1 tablespoon white vinegar

For Fried Shallots

  • 1-2 large shallots
  • 1 teaspoon cornstarch
  • vegetable oil for frying

For Smoked Ketchup

  • ½ cup ketchup
  • 1 clove garlic minced
  • 1 ½ teaspoons dijon mustard
  • ½ cup mayonnaise
  • ½ cup white vinegar
  • 1 tablespoon honey
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • ½ cup canola oil
  • 1/4-1/2 teaspoon liquid smoke or to taste

For the Pickled Onions

  • 2 red onions halved and sliced thin
  • 1 cup white vinegar
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt

For the Roasted Onions

  • 2 large yellow onions or red onions, peeled and sliced into half inch rings
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil or vegetable oil
  • 2 teaspoons kosher salt I only used about 3/4 teaspoon – cause we’re watching our salt intake

For the Sandwiches — each of the above recipes plus

  • 2 scallions thinly sliced
  • 4 Italian style sub rolls cut in half lengthwise


  • Slice the shallots into very thin rings and place in a bowl. Toss with cornstarch until the shallot rings have separated and the shallots feel dry. Heat about one inch of oil in a small shallow pan until to about 225°. Set paper towels on a plate and set aside. Add half the shallots to the pan and swirl with a slotted spoon. Cook until the shallots turn a blond color and immediately transfer to the paper towels. Turn the heat up on the oil to reach 325° — or hot enough that one of the already-fried shallots rings immediately sizzles when added to the oil. Fry the shallots a second time for 10-20 seconds until they puff slightly and caramelize. Transfer shallots back to the plate to cool.
  • Season the beef generously with salt. Melt the butter and combine with the fried shallots, chile powder, molasses, salt and white vinegar. “Rub it all over the beef like you want to spend the rest of your life with that beef and no other beef (but don’t make any promises to that beef or it will wind up hating you for the rest of its life). At this point it would be best to put that beef in a container and let it hang in the refrigerator overnight. But you’re impulsive and want to eat beef now. Okay, well then cook it, don’t be afraid; your parents always knew your were impulsive. That’s why, despite a lot of questioning and private conversations, they finally accepted your choice to be a cook instead of a college professor. Time heals all wounds, but roast beef waits for no man. Cook like you were born to do.”
  • I think that’s Tyler Kord speak for” best if refrigerated overnight, but can be made the same day”.
  • Preheat the oven to 250° Put the beef in a roasting pan and cook it for 2-2 1/2 hours. Use a meat thermometer to determine doneness… 120° for rare, 140° for medium. I’m going for 130°.
  • When the beef is cooked, remove from the oven and let it rest for half an hour before covering and refrigerating until well chilled. (It’s easier to slice thinly when the meat is chilled).

Make the Smoked French Dressing

  • The recipe actually calls for smoking the ketchup — as in building smoking apparatus on the grill. While we smoke things all the time, I just didn’t have the temerity to to go through the ministrations on this one and I used the alternative that he suggested — liquid smoke — but he warns not to use too much otherwise it will taste like “cheap ham”. Into a blender combine all the ingredients for the Smoked French Dressing and blend until smooth. Store in the refrigerator for up to a week.

Make the pickled onions

  • Combine everything in a plastic container with a tight fitting lid. Shake vigorously like you hate pickled red onions. (I swear the recipe says that). Let sit for at least 30 minutes but preferably longer, shaking occasionally. These will last for a very long time in your fridge.

Make the Roasted Onions

  • Preheat the oven to 450°. In a medium bowl, toss the onions, oil and salt together until thoroughly mixed. Place the onions on a baking sheet and cook until somewhat tender and a little burnt, about 20 minutes.

Assemble the Sandwich

  • Use a very sharp knife and slice the beef as thinly as humanly possible (he calls for a half pound of beef per sandwich – I’m not physically capable of eating that much meat on a sandwich, so I used about 1/4 pound).
  • Preheat the oven to 375°. Place the bread on a baking sheet, cut side up. Put some of the roasted onions on each half. Put them in the oven and cook until the onions are warm and the bread is toasted, about 6 minutes. Put 1/2 pound (his instruction, not mine) of roast beef on each of the 4 bottom pieces of bread. Drizzle some smoked French dressing on each sandwich. Top each sandwich with a quarter of the pickled red onions, fried shallots and scallions. Put the tops on the sandwiches and serve.


Tasting notes — I would add some fresh cilantro leaves to this sandwich.


Calories: 747kcal | Carbohydrates: 34g | Protein: 50g | Fat: 43g | Saturated Fat: 9g | Cholesterol: 146mg | Sodium: 1646mg | Potassium: 659mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 15g | Vitamin A: 795IU | Vitamin C: 6.5mg | Calcium: 52mg | Iron: 10.3mg

“Pin It” For Later!

The best roast beef sandwich recipe is Don't Cry For Me Argentina Roast Beef Sandwiches, with crispy fried shallots, pickled onions & smoky sauce plus tender medium rare roast beef. Heavenly! #roastbeef #beef #sandwiches #sandwich #roastbeefsandwich #shallots #specialsauce #onions #pickledonions #comfortfood #gamedaysandwich #superbowlfood #superbowlsnacks #tailgatingsandwich #tailgating

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.